Court dismisses second tithing fraud lawsuit on First Amendment grounds
September 3, 2026 at 11:03 AM MT · via The Salt Lake Tribune · Summarized by Mormon News from original reporting

A federal appeals court has dismissed another lawsuit claiming The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints fraudulently collected tithing, ruling the case was filed too late and that courts cannot adjudicate religious spending decisions, according to The Salt Lake Tribune.
The decision effectively closes the door on future litigation stemming from IRS whistleblower David Nielsen's 2019 allegations that the Church improperly accumulated $100 billion in tax-exempt funds. The court found the statute of limitations had expired and that the First Amendment bars judicial review of how churches use donated funds.
This is the second tithing fraud case dismissed on similar grounds. Nielsen's original complaint to the IRS led to multiple lawsuits by members claiming they were deceived about how tithing would be spent. The Church has maintained its financial practices comply with tax law.
More coverage of this story
- Deseret News →August 31, 2026 at 1:39 PM MT
- Courthouse News →August 31, 2026 at 2:35 PM MT
- YouTube / Mormon Discussion Inc. →August 31, 2026 at 8:22 PM MT
- By Common Consent →September 1, 2026 at 7:44 AM MT
- Deseret News →August 31, 2026 at 1:39 PM MT
Mormon News summarizes reporting from established outlets and always links to the original. See an error? Report it.
From the Mormon News Podcast
- LDS Church Caught Lying, Charlie Bird Breaking Point, Bishop Charged - Mormon News 9.4.26 | Ep. 2189
Full episode and transcript · September 4, 2026
- Bloomberg Exposes Mormon Land Empire, Baseball Baptisms & More - Mormon News 8.28.26 | Ep. 2187
Full episode and transcript · August 28, 2026
Related coverage
- Protestant scholar defends Joseph Smith against fraud claims
via YouTube · September 5, 2026
- Federal appeals court upholds dismissal of tithing fraud lawsuit
via ABC4 Utah · September 5, 2026
- Appeals court upholds dismissal of second LDS tithing fraud lawsuit
via ABC4 Utah · September 4, 2026
- Charlie Bird pulls back from sharing fatherhood journey after hateful messages
via YouTube / Mormon Stories Podcast · September 4, 2026