Ex-missionary describes mental health crisis from religious scrupulosity
September 16, 2026 at 2:03 PM MT · via YouTube / Cults to Consciousness · Summarized by Mormon News from original reporting
Justin Shoemaker describes how religious scrupulosity and intrusive thoughts sent him into a devastating mental health crisis during his Mormon mission, in a video on the Cults to Consciousness YouTube channel that has gained nearly 50,000 views in 27 hours. Raised in an intensely devout household, Shoemaker believed happiness came from following every church rule exactly.
After returning home early from his mission, Shoemaker attended BYU-Idaho before eventually leaving the faith. The video examines how perfectionism and obsessive-compulsive patterns intersect with high-demand religious environments. Religious scrupulosity — excessive concern about sin and moral purity — affects some members in traditions that emphasize worthiness and obedience.
Mormon News summarizes reporting from established outlets and always links to the original. See an error? Report it.
Related coverage
- Sen. John Curtis breaks with Trump, calls for AI regulations
via KSL · September 16, 2026
- Officer reflects on FLDS children removed in 2008 raid
via Idaho State Journal · September 16, 2026
- Maine parents battle in court over children's religious upbringing
via Deseret News · September 16, 2026
- Should LDS leaders speak out against sports betting?
via The Salt Lake Tribune · September 16, 2026
From the Mormon News Podcast
- LDS Church Caught Lying, Charlie Bird Breaking Point, Bishop Charged - Mormon News 9.4.26 | Ep. 2189
Full episode and transcript · September 4, 2026
- Bloomberg Exposes Mormon Land Empire, Baseball Baptisms & More - Mormon News 8.28.26 | Ep. 2187
Full episode and transcript · August 28, 2026