BYU landed at No. 9 in the College Football Playoff selection committee's first rankings of the 2026 season, released Tuesday night. The Cougars' placement came as a disappointment to some observers who expected a higher ranking given their undefeated record.

Sports Illustrated's analysis notes the committee appeared to value quality of wins over strength of schedule in the initial top 25. BYU's ranking places them behind several teams with losses, raising questions about how the committee weighs different factors.

The Cougars face No. 3 Utah this weekend in a rivalry matchup that could significantly shift both teams' playoff positioning. Utah debuted at No. 3, their highest-ever CFP ranking, setting up the most consequential Holy War game in years for national playoff implications.