Creator examines Joseph Smith quote about whipping children
August 20, 2026 at 9:07 PM MT · via YouTube / Analyzing Mormonism · Summarized by Mormon News from original reporting
An Analyzing Mormonism video examines a Joseph Smith quote stating "a parent may whip a child" from the controversial "happiness letter" to Nancy Rigdon. The video has drawn 1,266 views in 30 hours (~43/hr) and 19 comments.
The creator writes, "I think about this way too much… The whole Happiness Letter is problematic, of course, this part just also really strikes me." The letter, written circa mid-April 1842, was Joseph Smith's response to Nancy Rigdon after she declined his proposal.
The letter has been controversial for both its content and the circumstances surrounding Smith's approach to Rigdon. The video links to the Joseph Smith Papers transcription of the full letter.
Mormon News summarizes reporting from established outlets and always links to the original. See an error? Report it.
Related coverage
- BYU-Idaho highlights film exploring Joseph Smith's disputed photograph
via BYU-Idaho · October 5, 2026
- Utah Public Radio examines falling LDS birth rates, Trevor Lee charges
via Utah Public Radio · October 5, 2026
- Church adopts defensive posture toward criticism, columnist writes
via Religion News Service · October 5, 2026
- President Oaks declares distinctive LDS beliefs about divine parentage at conference
via Deseret News · October 5, 2026
From the Mormon News Podcast
- Nemo Goes Global, Mormon Stories Lawsuit Update & LDS Baby Bust - Mormon News 10.2.26 | Ep. 2204
Full episode and transcript · October 2, 2026
- LDS Retention Drop, Church Opposes Abortion Rights in Idaho, Nevada - Mormon News 9.25.26 | Ep. 2200
Full episode and transcript · September 25, 2026